CKB Pulse

All lessons · CKB node, RPC and indexer · Start here · Glossary

Rebuild an append-only on-chain accumulator from transaction history, not from live cellsAdvancedFrom one fix

From one fix · Check: right · Checked 2026-11-19

When a cell stores only the root of an append-only accumulator (an MMR) that commits to every entry ever added, spending an entry cell removes it from the indexer's live set while the root still counts it. Replaying live cells builds a different tree and membership proofs fail (the first refund works, the second fails). If each append transaction carries its entries in a witness and spends the previous head at input 0, recover the full set by walking get_transaction backwards through input 0 and parsing each witness with a strict exact-length check, so unrelated WitnessArgs or empty witnesses are not read as entries. Refuse to act unless the recovered count equals the frozen entry count, and fail if the node no longer serves an old transaction.

Why it matters: Membership proofs built by replaying only the indexer's live cells target a different tree than the committed root. Once one entry cell is spent, every later refund is refused on chain.

Joined with daowow@765895a407.

Pattern

Prefer
const replay = await readers.readShardEntries(rpc, ledger.outPoint, want); if (replay.length !== Number(want)) {

Taken from the commit, shortened.

A test changed in the same commit

It sits next to the fix. We did not run it.

Concepts
Indexer queries and cell collection, Witnesses and signatures
Evidence
From one fix: from one project, checked against its commit
First seen
2026-11-10
Last changed
2026-11-10
Last checked
2026-11-19
Check against the commit
right: the lesson follows from its commit and still holds in the code today

Sources (2)

More about CKB node, RPC and indexer

All 45 in this topic

Do you maintain a project this lesson came from? Confirm or correct it

Cite this lesson
LusoCryptoLabs, "Rebuild an append-only on-chain accumulator from transaction history, not from live cells", CKB lessons, https://pulse.lusocryptolabs.com/learned/node/rebuild-an-append-only-on-chain-accumulator-from-transaction, CC BY 4.0, last changed 2026-11-10.

Drawn from public commits and checked against the commit each one came from and the project's code today. Read the source before you rely on one. Text under CC BY 4.0: credit LusoCryptoLabs, CKB lessons, with a link to the lesson. Want a lesson changed or removed? Open an issue.